Skills on AI

Active theme: Light

Freedom of Information Request

Use when asked to draft or advise on a freedom of information request — a formal request to a government body for access to official records or information under public-records law (e.g. FOIA in the US, the FOI Act in the UK) — noting that the specific law, process, and exemptions vary by country and even by agency.

A freedom of information request is a formal ask, addressed to a government body, for access to official records or information it holds. It exists because most democracies give the public a legal right to see how government works, subject to specific exemptions — but the exact law, the agency's process, and what's exempt differ by country and often by agency within the same country, so this is general guidance, not a substitute for checking the applicable law.

Key components

  • A specific, well-scoped description of the records requested — the single biggest factor in whether a request succeeds quickly. Naming a specific document, decision, date range, and department gets a fast, complete answer; a vague ask for "everything relating to X" does not.
  • The relevant time period — bounding the request to the period that actually matters, rather than leaving it open-ended.
  • The requester's contact information — name and a way to reach them, since most regimes require this to process a request (some allow anonymous or third-party requests; check the local rule).
  • Awareness of likely exemptions — categories commonly withheld include ongoing law-enforcement investigations, personal privacy, national security, and internal deliberative communications, though the exact list and how narrowly each is applied varies by jurisdiction.
  • A stated format preference — electronic copies, paper, or in-person inspection, if the regime allows the requester to specify this.

Why over-broad requests routinely fail or get delayed

A body asked for "all records relating to X" spanning several years can legitimately take months to respond, charge substantial search or copying fees, or reject the request outright as unduly burdensome — even when every individual record would otherwise be releasable. A narrow request — a specific report, a specific meeting's minutes, a specific decision memo from a bounded date range — can often be answered in the statutory minimum time. Scoping tightly isn't just politeness; it's usually the difference between an answer in weeks and one that never comes, or comes so heavily redacted or delayed that it's no longer useful.

Common pitfalls

  • Request scoped so broadly it gets rejected or delayed for months — "all emails mentioning X" across years of correspondence invites a burden objection that a request for a specific set of emails, from a specific sender, in a specific week, would have avoided.
  • No awareness of the jurisdiction's specific exemptions — asking for a category that's obviously exempt (an open investigation's file, a named individual's personnel record) without narrowing around it stalls the entire request instead of yielding the releasable parts.
  • Follow-up and appeal rights not exercised — nearly every regime gives the requester some right to appeal a denial, challenge excessive delay, or ask for a fee waiver; letting a wrongful denial or a blown deadline go unchallenged forfeits a remedy that was actually available.
  • No record kept of the request and its deadline — without a tracked submission date and the statutory response window for that jurisdiction, it's hard to know when a delay has actually become actionable.
  • Assuming one country's process applies elsewhere — FOIA procedures, timelines, and exemptions in the US do not transfer directly to the UK's FOI Act, the EU's access-to-documents regime, or any other country's law; each has its own rules and appeal body.

Learn more

  • Policy Brief for turning records obtained through a request into a short, decision-oriented document for someone who needs to act on them.
  • Contract Review for the parallel discipline of reading a document closely for what it does and doesn't cover, applied to agreements rather than public records.

View freedom-of-information-request/SKILL.md on GitHub